Don’t Use Independence Day as a Chance to Shame America
Body
Don’t apologize this July 4th. Conscientious, well-meaning people often slip into this: “I know the United States is flawed, HOWEVER” or “We’ve made mistakes, BUT” and similar white noise. I understand the urge; these things are not untrue but they are profoundly unfitting and disordered. They are truisms. All men and all nations are flawed. It is impious and pointless to harp on it on a day set aside for celebration of what is good in the U.S. Seriously, who prefaces a eulogy, wedding speech or birthday card with disclaimers about the character of the person being celebrated? To paraphrase Chesterton, “a nation isn’t honored because it’s great, rather, it’s great because it’s honored.” The honor due isn’t contingent on the quality of the person or thing being honored, but on what it is in itself regardless of what it has done, for good or ill. Perhaps if on such occasions we refused to qualify our devotion into oblivion we’d become people who could create a country more perfectly worthy of devotion, rather than bunch of navel-gazing solipsists who turn every lofty human thing into a house of mirrors at a carnival. As Coolidge wrote in 1918, “Reverence is not the measure of others, but ourselves.” We fight for what we honor, not the other way round. For the record, anyone who refuses to honor this nation would dishonor any. The overturning of Roe v. Wade by the United States Supreme Court shows this nation has a greatness many refuse to see. Happy Independence Day weekend, 2022.